Proving Honor

Recover a fragment of Wuuthrad from Dustman’s Cairn with Farkas and join the Circle.

Proving Honor is the quest that turns the Companions from a rowdy mercenary guild into something much stranger. Skjor gives you one last trial before full membership: recover a fragment of Wuuthrad, Ysgramor’s legendary battle axe, from Dustman’s Cairn. Farkas comes along as your Shield-Brother to judge how you handle yourself, and he ends up revealing a lot more than he planned.

How to start

Finish the radiant job “Trouble in Skyrim” that Farkas hands you at the end of Take Up Arms. When the Companions say they have nothing more for you, speak to Skjor about the next steps. Then talk to Farkas and agree to meet him at the cairn. He temporarily replaces your current follower, who heads back home.

Walkthrough

Finding the entrance

The way in is easy to miss. Farkas waits on the path by some awkward, hard-to-climb rocks. Up the small hill there is a ring of standing stones around a pit; stairs at the south end lead down into it, and the door is near the bottom. Farkas immediately notices that someone has been digging here recently. Good instincts.

The trap

Clear the first room of draugr, go through the wooden door and down into a large cavern. In a side room stands a lever. Pulling it slams the exit shut and traps you behind a portcullis. Cue the cutscene: members of the Silver Hand, a band of werewolf hunters, corner Farkas, and he turns into a werewolf and tears through them. Talk to him afterwards about what just happened.

From here on Farkas mostly lets you do the work, only really joining in properly in the final room. The amount of help seems to depend on your level; lower-level characters reportedly get more support from him along the way.

Through the cairn

Push on through the caves, fighting Silver Hand members past two wooden doors, then up the stairs, past the burial urns and through another door. Look out for two chests before the stairs: one sits behind a hidden passage opened by a chain on the left-hand wall, the other is in the rubble of the hallway, with a coin purse behind the left door. More Silver Hand and draugr stand between you and the door to Dustman’s Crypt.

Dustman’s Crypt

More Silver Hand greet you on arrival. Take the side door, cross the bridge and head down to the right. Many draugr here are still asleep in their alcoves, so arrows, Destruction spells or long-reach melee can finish them before they even wake. In a large room, a chest off to the left holds Dustman’s Cairn Key, which opens the iron door ahead. Beyond it wait some skeevers, two frostbite spiders, more draugr, and a handy Alchemy Lab.

The fragment

The next iron door opens into the final chamber. The fragment sits on the altar, and the Word Wall behind it teaches a word of Fire Breath. Taking the fragment wakes a crowd of levelled draugr, which can include draugr deathlords at higher levels. Then climb the stairs and step through the empty coffin to reach a shortcut back to the entrance.

Return to Jorrvaskr

Back at the mead hall, Vilkas asks you to follow him into the courtyard. Farkas vouches for you and you are formally inducted into the Companions.

Rewards

  • A Skyforge Steel weapon of your choice.
  • You can now buy Skyforge Steel weapons and Wolf Armor from Eorlund Gray-Mane; they also turn up in the merchant chest under the Skyforge.
  • A Word of Power for Fire Breath.

Tips

  • Before grabbing the fragment, lay runes or cast Fireball near the draugr coffins to make them climb out early, so you can pick them off one at a time. Detect Dead shows you where they are lurking.
  • At higher levels Farkas is not much help in the last fight, and his heavy armor makes sneaking harder, so plan accordingly.
  • Farkas drops his Skyforge steel greatsword when he transforms. You can pick it up and keep it, or give it back later when he becomes available as a follower.
  • If you are overwhelmed in the crypt, slipping through the door back to Dustman’s Cairn can let you escape the Silver Hand.
  • Watch the coffins near the end: one Silver Hand member hides in one, pretending to be a draugr.

Trivia

  • Ask Farkas whether the Companions are all werewolves and he explains it is only the Circle, adding that it is a secret to everybody, a cheeky Legend of Zelda reference.
  • Despite the journal’s wording, you already count as a member after Take Up Arms for things like taking items in the hall or training Smithing with Eorlund.
  • Unused dialogue suggests Aela was once meant to join you on this quest.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Speak to Skjor
Speak to Farkas
Retrieve the fragment
Return to Jorrvaskr
Follow Vilkas

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Eorlund Gray-Mane is Whiterun’s master smith at the Skyforge – maker of Skyforge Steel, Master Smithing trainer and the man who reforges Wuuthrad for the Companions.
Farkas is the big-hearted Companion of Jorrvaskr – a werewolf, Heavy Armor trainer, follower and marriage candidate, and twin brother of Vilkas.
Skjor is the gruff veteran of the Companions’ Circle – a Great War survivor and werewolf who tests new Whelps and pulls you into the Circle’s secret.
Vilkas is the Companions’ sharp-tongued Master-at-Arms – a werewolf, Two-Handed trainer, follower and marriage candidate, and twin brother of Farkas.

Creatures you will meet

Draugr are the undead Nords guarding Skyrim’s ancient tombs. Variants, shouting Deathlords, and how to survive a barrow full of them.
Draugr Deathlord in Skyrim: level 30-40 undead boss of Nordic tombs with ebony weapons and Unrelenting Force. Stats, locations, loot and how to beat one.
Frostbite Spiders lurk in Skyrim’s caves and ruins, spitting venom from the ceiling. Variants, tactics and the ingredients they drop.
Skeevers are Skyrim’s giant rats – weak, everywhere and occasionally diseased. Where to find them and what the skeever tail is good for.
Werewolves in Skyrim: the blessing of Hircine, the Companions’ secret, how to become one and how to fight them with silver.

Locations

Dustman’s Cairn in Skyrim: Proving Honor walkthrough – Farkas, the Silver Hand ambush, draugr, the Wuuthrad fragment, Fire Breath Word Wall and secret exit.

Factions

The Companions are Skyrim’s legendary warrior guild in Jorrvaskr, Whiterun – honour, glory and a secret that howls at the moon. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database