Destroy the Dark Brotherhood! is the alternative path for players who would rather end the assassins than join them. It starts if you kill Astrid in the Abandoned Shack during “With Friends Like These…“, instead of one of her three captives. That fails the recruitment quest and puts you on the side of the Penitus Oculatus. Be warned: once this quest starts, joining the Dark Brotherhood is off the table for good.
Walkthrough
Kill Astrid
After Innocence Lost, you wake up in the shack in Hjaalmarch with Astrid and three hooded prisoners. Attack Astrid instead of the captives. She dies with a dry “Well done…”, which is a little ironic given what comes next. Loot the shack key from her body – it won’t show up if you try to pickpocket it beforehand. With Astrid gone, you can free the captives or, if you’re that sort of hero, kill them with no consequences.
Report to a guard
Tell any guard that you’ve killed a Dark Brotherhood assassin. The nearest ones are in Morthal, south of the shack. The guard sends you to Commander Maro at the Penitus Oculatus Outpost in Dragon Bridge.
Speak with Commander Maro
Maro has been tracking the Brotherhood for some time, waiting for an opening. With their leader dead, he hands you the passphrase his agents recently obtained – “Silence, my brother” – and orders you to kill every assassin in the Sanctuary.
Clear the Sanctuary
The Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary lies southwest of Falkreath. To finish, you must kill Nazir, Gabriella, Arnbjorn, Festus Krex and Veezara. Lis, the Sanctuary’s pet frostbite spider, is optional but will attack if she sees you.
This is a genuinely tough fight. The assassins hit hard, use a mix of weapons, magic and a werewolf, and the corridors are cramped. Followers won’t come inside with you, so you’re on your own.
Report back
Return to Maro to collect your reward. He doesn’t open a dialogue menu this time; he simply congratulates you.
Rewards
3,000 gold, plus Commander Maro’s friendship – he may even show up at your wedding.
What you give up
Choosing this path locks you out of a lot: Shadowmere, the Summon Spectral Assassin power, the Ancient Shrouded Armor, Dark Brotherhood Initiate followers, Cicero as a follower and his outfit, marrying Muiri, the Dawnstar Sanctuary, and at least 20,000 gold. A couple of these can reportedly still be reached another way: the Ancient Shrouded Armor sits in Hag’s End, and Muiri may become marriageable if she takes over the Hag’s Cure after Bothela dies (killing Bothela yourself lowers Muiri’s opinion of you).
On the bright side, the Falkreath Sanctuary stays intact and fully accessible, unlike at the end of the Brotherhood questline, and Brotherhood assassins stop ambushing you on the road.
Tips
- Bows, invisibility and poisons are your best tools inside the Sanctuary. Pick fights one at a time where you can.
- Spectral allies such as Arniel’s Shade do follow you in, unlike ordinary followers.
- With the Misdirection perk you can pickpocket Astrid’s equipment first, making her much easier to kill.
- Casting Calm on Sanctuary members lets you hear the dialogue they’d give a fellow member – Nazir just has no contracts for you.
Trivia
- Babette and Cicero aren’t in the Sanctuary, so they survive. Cicero is never seen again, and Babette never appears at all.
- Guards later praise you for wiping out the Brotherhood – one insists he’d have done it himself, but he was “sick that day”.
- Morrowind’s Tribunal expansion had a similar quest, “Hunt the Dark Brotherhood”.
Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.


