Innocence Lost

Answer Aventus Aretino’s Black Sacrament and kill Grelod the Kind in Riften.

Innocence Lost is how most players find the Dark Brotherhood – or rather, how the Brotherhood finds them. Rumours around Skyrim talk about a “cursed child” in Windhelm: a boy named Aventus Aretino who is performing the Black Sacrament to summon an assassin. It is the first quest of the Dark Brotherhood questline and leads straight into With Friends Like These…

How to start

There are plenty of ways in, and you don’t actually need to talk to anyone before visiting the boy:

  • Ask any innkeeper for rumours; sooner or later one mentions Aventus.
  • Ask Idesa Sadri in Candlehearth Hall about the child, or overhear her chatting with Grimvar Cruel-Sea outside the Aretino Residence.
  • Ask Maul about Dark Brotherhood rumours when you first arrive in Riften.
  • Visit Honorhall Orphanage in Riften, listen to Grelod’s charming speech, and ask any of the children about Aventus.
  • Simplest of all: pick the lock of the Aretino Residence and walk in. Guards gossiping about the boy won’t start the quest on their own, though.

Walkthrough

Talk to Aventus Aretino

The Aretino Residence is near the Gray Quarter in Windhelm. Inside, Aventus is mid-ritual, asking the Night Mother why no one has answered. His story is grim: after his mother died he was sent to Honorhall Orphanage, where the matron abused the children until he ran away. He is convinced you are the assassin he summoned – no matter how firmly you deny it – and asks you to kill Grelod the Kind. Mention that assassinations aren’t cheap and he promises something valuable.

Kill Grelod the Kind

Grelod is at the orphanage in Riften. She is rude from the first word, and passing on Aventus’ greetings makes her furious and unwilling to talk any further. As a fight she is no challenge at all: a single hit, even with bare fists, finishes her, or you can let a follower do it.

The children won’t report you to the guards – they cheer. Still, a bit of care helps:

  • Do the deed inside the orphanage.
  • Leave Constance Michel alone; harming her lands you a bounty in the Rift.
  • Grelod screams loudly when she dies. A sneaky kill in her bedroom with the door shut, using an arrow or bolt, keeps you hidden when everyone comes running.

Report back

Return to Aventus in Windhelm and tell him the news. He hands over his reward and can now go back to the orphanage and live out a far happier childhood.

Rewards

The Aretino Family Heirloom (base value 100 gold). More importantly, the quest sets up the Brotherhood’s first contact: sleep in any bed away from Windhelm and you’ll wake up somewhere unexpected, beginning With Friends Like These…

Tips

  • If you kill Grelod before ever speaking to Aventus, the Brotherhood won’t reach out straight away. Visit the boy afterwards – he is thrilled, the reward is the same, and contact follows.
  • Want to adopt an Honorhall child with Hearthfire? That’s only possible once Grelod is gone.

Trivia

  • Bring Serana into the Aretino Residence and she may start performing the ritual herself.
  • Riften’s guards are unusually understanding about Grelod’s death and suggest the kids are better off; guards elsewhere call it a tragedy. Riften guards may also wonder aloud whether they saw you leaving the orphanage.
  • Grelod carries a copy of The Pig Children, hinting at a dislike of Orcs on top of everything else.
  • Aventus’ muttering suggests he had been at the ritual for a long time. Astrid later implies she knew, but didn’t think a child’s contract worth taking – it is the only contract in the questline placed by a child.
  • In Oblivion, two Brotherhood members discuss a contract on a nanny at an orphanage, a neat bit of foreshadowing.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Talk to Aventus Aretino
Kill Grelod the Kind
Tell Aventus Aretino that Grelod is dead

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Astrid is the Nord leader of the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim – the woman who kidnaps you into her “family” from the Falkreath Sanctuary.
Aventus Aretino is the runaway boy performing the Black Sacrament in Windhelm – his contract on Grelod the Kind starts Innocence Lost and the Dark Brotherhood questline.
Constance Michel in Skyrim: kind caretaker at Riften’s Honorhall Orphanage who replaces Grelod and handles adoptions with the Hearthfire DLC.
Grelod the Kind in Skyrim: the cruel headmistress of Honorhall Orphanage in Riften, hated by the children and the target of the quest Innocence Lost.
Grimvar Cruel-Sea in Skyrim: the Cruel-Sea family’s boy in Windhelm who dreams of killing dragons and spreads gossip about Aventus Aretino’s ritual.
Idesa Sadri in Skyrim: the Dunmer nanny of Grimvar Cruel-Sea in Windhelm, who worries about the Butcher and Aventus Aretino’s Black Sacrament.
Maul in Skyrim: Maven Black-Briar’s Nord enforcer in Riften. Ex-Thieves Guild, brother of Dirge, he warns newcomers and sells information for coin.
Night Mother in Skyrim: the ghostly leader of the Dark Brotherhood who speaks only to the Listener. Her role in Whispers in the Dark, Death Incarnate and more.

Creatures you will meet

Locations

Candlehearth Hall in Skyrim: Windhelm’s inn by the gate – innkeeper, Stenvar the sellsword, the Blood on the Ice murders and the eternal candle explained.
Gray Quarter in Skyrim: Windhelm’s Dark Elf district – New Gnisis Cornerclub, Sadri’s Used Wares, Dunmer refugees, residents, quests and Civil War politics.
Riften is the canal city of the Rift – autumn forests, the Black-Briar family, the Temple of Mara and the Thieves Guild beneath its streets.
Windhelm is the ancient, snow-covered capital of Eastmarch and the Stormcloak stronghold – home of Ulfric Stormcloak’s Palace of the Kings and the Gray Quarter.

Factions

The Dark Brotherhood is Skyrim’s guild of assassins – the Night Mother, the Listener and a contract that could shake the Empire. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database