With Friends Like These…

Kill one of three captives for Astrid to join the Dark Brotherhood – or kill Astrid.

With Friends Like These… is the Dark Brotherhood‘s idea of a job interview. It follows Innocence Lost: a few days after Grelod’s death, a courier hands you a note bearing a black hand print and two unsettling words – “We Know”. Go to sleep somewhere away from Windhelm and you wake up in an Abandoned Shack in the marshes of Hjaalmarch, north of Morthal, with Astrid perched nearby and three bound, hooded captives. Depending on what you do here, the story continues with Sanctuary or with Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!

Walkthrough

The Mysterious Note

The courier usually shows up within one to three days, sooner if you sleep or hang around towns. Sleeping in a bed outside Windhelm then triggers the abduction – occasionally even before the note arrives.

Meeting Astrid

Astrid explains the situation: the Brotherhood is quite happy Grelod is dead, but Aventus performed the Black Sacrament, which means you stole their kill. You owe them one. The three captives are Fultheim the Fearless, Alea Quintus and Vasha. Someone has paid for one of them to die, and Astrid isn’t telling who. You can question all three before deciding.

Paying the debt

Kill one of the captives – or two, or all three if you are in an efficient mood. Astrid is satisfied either way, unlocks the door and tells you where to find the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary in the pine forest near Falkreath. Each choice earns its own sardonic comment from her.

The Black Door

At the Sanctuary, the Black Door asks: “What is the music of life?” The answer is “Silence, my brother.” Guesses about lutes, drums, screaming or chanting choirs get you rejected. Inside, speak with Astrid to complete the quest and become part of the family.

The other option: kill Astrid

You can turn the knife on Astrid instead. This fails the quest, ends any chance of joining the Brotherhood, and starts Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!, beginning with reporting the events to a guard. Loot the shack key from her body to get out. With Astrid dead, you can untie and free all three captives – or kill them without being charged with murder.

Rewards

  • Joining: membership in the Dark Brotherhood and a full set of Shrouded Armor from Astrid.
  • Killing Astrid: her Shrouded Armor and the Blade of Woe, looted from her body.

Tips

  • Entering the Sanctuary before starting Delayed Burial will fail that quest, so sort it out first if you care.
  • You cannot leave the shack without killing at least one captive or Astrid. Pickpocketing the key doesn’t work – it only appears on her corpse.
  • Followers aren’t with you in the shack but rejoin as soon as you step outside. Fast travel is blocked because of “enemies nearby”.
  • Turning a captive into something else with the Wabbajack counts as a kill.
  • Casting Clairvoyance picks a target at random, so it won’t reveal the “right” answer.

Trivia

  • The title riffs on the saying “With friends like these, who needs enemies?”
  • No time passes while you are “asleep”, and your Hours Slept statistic isn’t updated, though you still get the Rested bonus.
  • The black execution hoods worn by the captives can only be found here, short of console commands. They can be pickpocketed.
  • Freed captives don’t actually leave the shack, and the captives resist reverse-pickpocketed poisons and paralysis.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Kill one of the captives
Speak with Astrid
Enter the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary
Speak with Astrid

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Kill a captive: join the Brotherhood. Kill Astrid: start Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Astrid is the Nord leader of the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim – the woman who kidnaps you into her “family” from the Falkreath Sanctuary.

Creatures you will meet

Locations

Abandoned Shack in Skyrim: the locked, bloody cabin where Astrid tests Dark Brotherhood recruits – three captives, the key, Blade of Woe and Shrouded Armor.
Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary in Skyrim: hidden assassin lair west of Falkreath – Black Door passphrase, members, Marked for Death Word Wall, loot and quests.
Falkreath is the quiet forest town of southern Skyrim with a famously large graveyard – home of Jarl Siddgeir, the Dead Man’s Drink and a talking dog called Barbas.
Morthal is the misty swamp town of Hjaalmarch – ruled by the seer Jarl Idgrod Ravencrone, home of the wizard Falion and a dark mystery about a burned house.
Windhelm is the ancient, snow-covered capital of Eastmarch and the Stormcloak stronghold – home of Ulfric Stormcloak’s Palace of the Kings and the Gray Quarter.

Factions

The Dark Brotherhood is Skyrim’s guild of assassins – the Night Mother, the Listener and a contract that could shake the Empire. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database