The Black Star is the darker version of Azura’s Star: a reusable soul gem that can also hold black souls – the souls of people. For serious enchanters it’s arguably the better choice. It weighs nothing, is worth 1,000 gold and counts as a Daedric artifact, so it also ticks a box towards the Oblivion Walker achievement.
How to get it
In The Black Star, bring the broken star to the mage Nelacar instead of Azura’s priestess Aranea Ienith. After you deal with the necromancer Malyn Varen’s soul trapped inside it, you get the Black Star.
Step by step
- Start the quest by speaking to Aranea at the Shrine of Azura, south of Winterhold (you need to be at least level 8).
- Find Nelacar in The Frozen Hearth and talk, bribe or threaten him into telling you about his mentor’s experiments.
- Travel to Ilinalta’s Deep, a half-sunken Imperial outpost west of Riverwood, and take the Broken Azura’s Star from Malyn’s remains.
- Return to Nelacar rather than Aranea and tell him you are ready to enter the Star.
- Inside, Malyn first mistakes you for a fresh soul sent by his followers, then flees down a path guarded by three Dremora. Corner him and destroy his soul; he fights with a leveled Destruction staff and a dagger.
What it does
A reusable black soul gem. Black souls (people) are always grand, and it can hold white souls too – one soul at a time. When you use the soul it simply empties instead of disappearing, ready for the next victim.
Nelacar insists it can only take black souls. He is wrong: like an ordinary black soul gem it accepts creature souls as well, which is more of a developer oversight than a bug, and a very welcome one.
Why many players pick it over Azura’s Star
- Grand souls everywhere: bandits, necromancers and other humanoid enemies are common, and every one of them carries a grand soul. Grand white souls, by contrast, only come from heavyweights such as a Mammoth.
- Fast Enchanting: a steady stream of grand souls makes it one of the quickest ways to train Enchanting, especially paired with a Soul Trap weapon.
- A new merchant: after the quest Nelacar sells mage robes, spell tomes, soul gems and the occasional staff.
The trade-off is that you do not get Aranea as a follower, which only happens if you side with Azura.
Tips
- Your other compatible soul gems are filled before the Black Star, so a pocket full of cheap gems will be used first.
- If you are a vampire hoping to be cured by Falion, note that his ritual needs a regular filled black soul gem – the Black Star will not do.
- Ilinalta’s Deep has an arcane enchanter and an alchemy lab, handy for testing your new toy on the spot.
Lore background
Malyn Varen was exiled from the College of Winterhold for his soul gem research. Azura’s Star normally refuses black souls, so he spent years altering it until it would accept one – his own – granting him a twisted kind of immortality. Azura tormented him for it, and the artifact slowly drove him mad. Choosing Nelacar keeps his corruption of the Star, minus the man himself.
Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.


