Darkness Returns is the quest that wraps up the Nightingale story in the Thieves Guild questline. With Mercer gone after Blindsighted, you are left holding the Skeleton Key – and an oath that says it goes back where it belongs: the Ebonmere in the Twilight Sepulcher. Karliah comes along for the trip. Finishing it opens the way to Under New Management.
Walkthrough
Entering the Sepulcher
Just inside you meet the ghost of Gallus Desidenius, the Nightingale Mercer murdered. He explains that with the Key missing, the other spirits of the Sepulcher have turned hostile. Ask him about the obstacles ahead and he points you towards the remains of an earlier adventurer, Nystrom, lying to the east. Nystrom’s journal (optional, but handy) contains a short riddle for each trial on the Pilgrim’s Path, plus some mumbling about how “night is the new day”. Keep that phrase in mind.
First trial – the Sentinels
The first room is guarded by Nightingale Sentinels: ghostly, hostile and hard-hitting. You can sneak past them or fight. A Sentinel usually stands right in front of you as you enter, which makes it an easy sneak-attack target for archers. Killing the rest is optional but rewarded, as there is good loot on both sides of the area. In the side room with the alchemy lab, look for a button under the desk, to the left of the chair – it opens a secret door with a modest stash behind it.
Second trial – light versus dark
Here the journal’s hint pays off: stay in the shadows and keep to the darkest route. Standing in or walking through the lit patches hurts a lot, and the damage is scripted, so not even Become Ethereal saves you. There are no enemies in this section, but watch for tripwires on the staircases. If you struggle to see, Candlelight and Magelight are safe to use – your own light does not count against you.
Third trial – the hidden door
In the room with the statue (and a less fortunate bandit lying in front of it), there are two large sconces either side of the statue. Find the chain to the left of the left sconce and the chain to the right of the right sconce, and pull both. Putting out the lights gives Nocturnal what she wants most – darkness – and the door behind the statue opens.
Fourth trial – traps and Sentinels
- Skip the traps: before the first hallway with swinging axes, a Master-locked iron door on the left lets you bypass the whole gauntlet. Conveniently, you are carrying a key that opens anything.
- Brave the traps: move carefully, or use Whirlwind Sprint or Become Ethereal. The axes can pass on diseases, reportedly even to werewolves and vampires.
- Open the next door from the side, as a battering ram swings out of it. Don’t take the west door yet; head south first.
- In the following room, deal with the Sentinels and loot the pit. Among the goodies are two skill books: Proper Lock Design (on the southern table) and Sacred Witness.
Then head north into the Inner Sanctum. A point of no return is close, so finish looting first.
Fifth trial – the Inner Sanctum
You reach a steep pit. Once you drop in, the first part of the Sepulcher is sealed behind you. Jump down, search the skeleton of Anders and read his note, then wait a moment for the Key to react. The floor gives way, and when you land, place the Skeleton Key in the Ebonmere Lock. Nocturnal appears and makes it very clear that you have merely done what you swore to do – then invites you to drink from the Ebonmere.
Choosing a Nightingale role
Karliah explains the three paths. You pick one by stepping onto the matching moon symbol. Each grants a greater power usable once per day:
- Agent of Stealth (crescent moon) – Nightingale Shadows: turn invisible while crouching for 120 seconds, much like The Shadow Stone.
- Agent of Subterfuge (half moon) – Nightingale Subterfuge: for 30 seconds, people and creatures in the area attack whoever is near them.
- Agent of Strife (full moon) – Nightingale Strife: instantly absorbs 100 Health from the target, and can pass through to hit others behind it.
No need to agonise: you can switch your choice later, once a day has passed. Afterwards, speak to Karliah again; Gallus’ ghost appears for a final word before departing for the Evergloam, and Karliah heads back to Nightingale Hall. Leave through the southern portal.
Rewards
One of the three Nightingale blessings, plus a big step towards leading the guild.
Tips
- A stealthy build makes this quest far smoother – both the Sentinels and the light trial reward a quiet approach.
- Loot everything before the pit in the Inner Sanctum; there is no going back.
- If you are unsure which blessing to take, Stealth pairs naturally with sneak archery, while Strife is a handy emergency heal-and-damage button.
Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.


