Whispers in the Dark is where the Dark Brotherhood story takes a sharp turn. After Mourning Never Comes, Astrid pulls you aside with a worry: Cicero, the jester who arrived with the Night Mother‘s remains, keeps locking himself in her chamber and whispering to someone. Astrid suspects a conspiracy against the Sanctuary and wants you to find out who he is talking to. The answer is rather more interesting than she expects.
Walkthrough
Hide in the Night Mother’s coffin
The coffin stands in the room of the Sanctuary with the stained glass window. It has a Novice lock, so any lockpicker will manage. Climb inside, get comfortable next to a centuries-old corpse, and wait.
Eavesdrop on Cicero
Cicero comes in and starts talking – to the Night Mother herself. It soon becomes clear he has been doing this for a long time without ever getting a reply, and at one point he loses patience and shouts at her. Then the Night Mother lights up and speaks, but not to him. She tells you that you are the one: Cicero can’t hear her because he is not the Listener. She gives you two instructions:
- Seek out Amaund Motierre in the Nordic ruin of Volunruud and accept his contracts.
- Tell Cicero a phrase: “Darkness rises when silence dies.”
Talk to Cicero
The coffin opens and Cicero is livid, accusing you of defiling his beloved Mother. Astrid walks in to see what the noise is about. Repeat the Night Mother’s phrase and Cicero’s fury turns instantly to joy: he proclaims you the Listener of the Dark Brotherhood.
Talk to Astrid
Astrid is far less delighted. Hearing about Volunruud, she orders you to stay away until she has worked out what this means – her authority as head of the Sanctuary has just been undercut by a talking corpse. Instead, she sends you to Nazir for more contract work.
Get a contract from Nazir
Accept a side contract from Nazir and the quest completes. The available jobs at this point include the contracts on Lurbuk and Hern. The main story continues with The Silence Has Been Broken.
Choices
You can ignore Astrid and head for Volunruud straight away. Amaund Motierre is already waiting there and greets you either way. The catch: back at the Sanctuary, Astrid won’t talk to you, and you can’t hand over the amulet and letter until Nazir’s contract is done. So you might as well do things in her order.
Rewards
No gold this time, but a big promotion: you become the Listener, the one member of the Brotherhood who hears the Night Mother’s voice.
Trivia
- Inside the coffin your view is locked on the Night Mother so you don’t miss her speech. Enter while sneaking and you may end up staring at her waist instead, which makes the scene a lot less dramatic.
- This is the moment that sets Astrid and Cicero on very different paths regarding you, and it shapes much of the rest of the questline.
Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.


