Mourning Never Comes is your first proper contract for Astrid in the Dark Brotherhood questline. Someone in Markarth has performed the Black Sacrament: Muiri, the apothecary’s assistant at the Hag’s Cure. Her target is Alain Dufont – the bandit who seduced her and used her to rob the Shatter-Shield family – and she has a bonus job if you are feeling thorough. The quest follows Sanctuary and leads into Whispers in the Dark.
Walkthrough
Get the contract
Astrid offers this job once you have finished at least one of Nazir’s first three contracts. Talk to her in the Sanctuary and she points you to Markarth.
Talk to Muiri
During shop hours Muiri is usually at work in the Hag’s Cure. She explains what Dufont did and why she wants him dead, then adds an optional target: Nilsine Shatter-Shield in Windhelm. Run through all her dialogue and she also hands you two vials of Lotus Extract – keep them, they come in handy.
Kill Alain Dufont
Dufont is holed up with his gang in the Dwemer ruin of Raldbthar. Depending on your level there may be bandits outside, and one is usually asleep on the left just inside. There are two ways to reach him:
- The direct route: go past the flames to a locked gate that leads straight into the room where Dufont sits with two bandits. Slipping through the flames (or squeezing around the right side of the right-hand post) is often easier than the long way if your Sneak is low.
- The high road: work your way up and around the ruin, through a Master-locked gate, to a platform above Dufont. Here two levers control a pair of Dwarven ballista traps aimed at the room below.
Some ways to make it easy:
- Lure the bandits towards the campfire (shoot an arrow at it, or use Throw Voice) and then fire the ballista aimed at them. Oddly, bandits sitting in their chairs survive the bolts, so get them on their feet first.
- There is a puddle of oil beneath Dufont. A fire spell or an exploding bolt can set it alight and catch him and his friends together.
- A sneaky archer can simply shoot Dufont; his companion tends not to search for long.
- Werewolves can transform in the room before Dufont and keep everyone fleeing with Howl of Terror.
- Mages can send in a Flaming Familiar from a safe distance. Dufont isn’t hostile until attacked, so a touch of Fury may be needed to make the Familiar go for him.
Kill Nilsine Shatter-Shield (optional)
Nilsine lives in Windhelm; making the quest active and following the marker is the easiest way to find her. Ideas for a clean kill:
- Around 9 PM she goes to mourn her dead sister at the Hall of the Dead or the Temple of Talos. One dose of Muiri’s lotus poison finishes her without raising suspicion.
- Pickpocket her house key during the day, or pick the Master lock, and sneak-attack her in bed at night.
- The shadowy little staircase between the residential district and the graveyard is a quiet spot to catch her on her way home.
- Cast Fury on her so she attacks the guards. If seen, the bounty is small – far less than a witnessed murder.
Note: if Dufont is already dead before you start the quest, Muiri gets nervous and never offers the Nilsine job.
Report back
Return to Muiri in Markarth for payment, then speak to Astrid to finish the contract.
Rewards
- 600–1,200 gold from Muiri, scaling with your level.
- Muiri’s Ring, if you also killed Nilsine.
Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.


