The Cure for Madness

Hunt the mad jester Cicero to the Dawnstar Sanctuary – kill him or spare him.

The Cure for Madness is the Dark Brotherhood quest where Cicero finally snaps. Returning to the Falkreath Sanctuary after Breaching Security, you learn the jester has attacked his fellow assassins and fled. Your job is to track him down to the abandoned Dawnstar Sanctuary and deal with him – one way or another.

Walkthrough

1. Find out what happened

Gabriella meets you at the door of the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary and sends you straight to Astrid. She explains that Cicero went berserk, tried to murder everyone and then ran. Her suggestion: search his room for clues.

2. Read Cicero’s journal

The final volume of Cicero’s Journal lies on the end table next to his bed; the earlier volumes are scattered on raised surfaces nearby. The last one reveals the location and password of an old, disused Sanctuary near Dawnstar. Tell Astrid, and she orders you to kill him. While you are in the Sanctuary, Nazir can hand out extra side contracts.

3. Behold Shadowmere

Astrid lends you Shadowmere, the Brotherhood’s black horse, who rises out of the dark pool outside the Sanctuary. Collecting him is optional – you can fast travel to Dawnstar instead – but he is well worth having.

4. Talk to Arnbjorn

Arnbjorn is sitting wounded just outside the Dawnstar Sanctuary. He fought Cicero and claims he hurt the jester just as badly, so all you need to do is follow the blood. Send him home and head inside.

5. Through the Dawnstar Sanctuary

Cicero taunts you throughout the dungeon. Highlights along the way:

  • A full Jester’s Outfit on a table to the left in the first room.
  • A bridge with a spear trap – you can lure a Sanctuary Guardian across it into the spikes.
  • At the bottom of a spiral staircase: the skill books The Marksmanship Lesson (Archery) and Fire and Darkness (One-handed), plus Worn Shrouded Armor on a cupboard.
  • A fire trap in the next room, guarded by more Sanctuary Guardians.

In the following room, pull the chain at the foot of the south-west stairs. This opens a round passage in the north-east wall and reveals a barred door in the south-east corner. Ignore the stairs (they loop back) and take the round opening into an ice cave, which Cicero sarcastically calls a “forced addition”. The unique troll Udefrykte lives here among dead animals and bear traps; a ledge on the left leads to a chest with a few coins.

Further on, a wooden door leads to a pole gate (chain on the right wall) and a corridor of coffins, some holding Bone Meal. A dead end to the south hides a master-locked chest with leveled loot. Climb the stairs to the north, open another pole gate, and you reach the barred door from earlier and Cicero’s room.

The choice

Cicero lies on the floor, apparently badly injured, and begs you to spare him and lie to Astrid. You can kill Cicero – or leave him alive and walk away.

  • Spare him: no effect on the quest or on how the Brotherhood treats you, and Cicero later becomes a follower.
  • Kill him: loot his outfit (stronger than the one at the entrance), some gold and a leveled dagger. If you attack, he jumps up and fights – the injuries were an act.

Either way, report back to Astrid. She thanks you, tells you to keep Shadowmere a while longer, and starts the next contract, Recipe for Disaster.

Rewards

Shadowmere, and Cicero as a follower if spared – or his loot if not.

Tips

  • Want the outfit and a living Cicero? With the Perfect Touch and Poisoned pickpocket perks, slip him a paralysis poison and take his clothes while he is frozen. The Paralyze spell or a Staff of Paralysis works too.
  • Cicero’s 500 gold can be taken twice by pickpocketing him before you attack. If he catches you, sheathe your weapons and he will curl back up.
  • Planning to kill him safely? Unbar the door opposite his room, back off to the steps and shoot him with a sneaking bow; he keeps lying back down between shots.
  • With Perfect Touch you can also pickpocket Shrouded Armor from the Sanctuary Guardians.

Trivia

  • Killing Cicero counts toward charging the Ebony Blade.
  • If the Ghost of Lucien Lachance is with you, he warns that killing the Keeper goes against the Dread Father’s wishes.
  • The quest stage for “Behold Shadowmere” is, fittingly, 666. If you skip the horse, that objective can linger in your journal after the quest is complete.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Talk to Astrid
Search Cicero’s room
Read Cicero’s diary
Talk to Astrid
Behold Shadowmere
Locate Arnbjorn
Talk to Arnbjorn
Enter the Dawnstar Sanctuary
Kill Cicero or leave the Sanctuary
Report back to Astrid

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Kill Cicero or spare him. If spared, he becomes a follower after Hail Sithis!.

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Arnbjorn is the Nord werewolf of the Dark Brotherhood and husband of Astrid – the gruff guard of the Falkreath Sanctuary in Skyrim.
Astrid is the Nord leader of the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim – the woman who kidnaps you into her “family” from the Falkreath Sanctuary.
Cicero is the Dark Brotherhood’s mad jester and Keeper of the Night Mother – an essential assassin follower if you spare his life.
Gabriella is the poetic Dunmer assassin of the Dark Brotherhood in the Falkreath Sanctuary – the one who helps you plan Breaching Security and talks fondly of death.
Nazir is the dry-humoured Redguard assassin who hands out the Dark Brotherhood’s side contracts – and a master Light Armor trainer.

Creatures you will meet

Shadowmere in Skyrim: the Dark Brotherhood’s red-eyed horse. How to get him from Astrid, 1637 health, fast regeneration, respawning and where he waits.
Udefrykte in Skyrim: unique level 22 troll in the Dawnstar Sanctuary ice cave during The Cure for Madness. Weak to fire, tactics, Troll Fat loot and trivia.

Locations

Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary in Skyrim: hidden assassin lair west of Falkreath – Black Door passphrase, members, Marked for Death Word Wall, loot and quests.
Dawnstar is the cold northern port of the Pale – a mining town plagued by nightmares, home of Jarl Skald the Elder, the Windpeak Inn and a Mythic Dawn museum.
Dawnstar Sanctuary in Skyrim: the Dark Brotherhood’s hidden home behind the Black Door – passphrase, Cicero’s fate, upgrades, skill books and Shrouded gear.

Factions

The Dark Brotherhood is Skyrim’s guild of assassins – the Night Mother, the Listener and a contract that could shake the Empire. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database