Speaking With Silence

Hunt Karliah in Snow Veil Sanctum with Mercer Frey and learn the truth about Gallus’ murder.

Speaking With Silence is the turning point of the Thieves Guild questline. Straight after Scoundrel’s Folly, Mercer Frey arranges to meet you outside Snow Veil Sanctum, an old Nordic tomb in Winterhold hold, northwest of Windhelm. It is Karliah‘s last known hiding place, and the plan is to make her pay for the murder of Gallus, the former Guild Master. Things do not go to plan. At least, not to yours.

How to start

Mercer gives you the quest as soon as you report back to him at the end of Scoundrel’s Folly. The next quest is Hard Answers.

Walkthrough

Meet Mercer at Snow Veil Sanctum

Travel to the sanctum and talk to Mercer, who unlocks the door. If he refuses to budge, you can reportedly push him along with Unrelenting Force, which is a very satisfying solution.

Fight through the tomb

Inside, you and Mercer carve your way through draugr. Watch out for tripwire traps along the way. Partway through you will spot a Model Ship sitting on a trapped pressure plate. It is a larceny target that Delvin Mallory buys for 300 to 800 gold depending on your level, so it is worth the risk. Mercer will tell you that you are rather noisy for a thief whatever your Sneak level, so try not to take it personally.

The Word Wall

Eventually you reach a Word Wall that teaches a word of Disarm. Three draugr wake up here. The same room holds the Light Armor skill book Ice and Chitin.

The puzzle door and the ambush

Next comes a dragon claw puzzle door. Normally you need the right claw, but this time Mercer opens it himself. Step through and you are hit by a poisoned arrow. The shot is scripted and cannot be avoided. Paralysed on the floor, you can only watch as Mercer and Karliah face each other, and you learn the truth about who really killed Gallus. When they are done, Mercer walks over, promises to give Brynjolf your regards, and stabs you. Everything goes black.

Wake up at Karliah’s camp

Hours later you wake up at a makeshift camp outside the sanctum, where Karliah has been tending to you. Her arrow turns out to have saved your life. Talk to her. She explains Mercer’s betrayal and tells you she has recovered Gallus’s journal, but it is written in a strange language that needs translating. The quest ends here.

Rewards

  • Gallus’s Encoded Journal, which drives the next quest.
  • A Word of Power for Disarm.
  • A whole new perspective on your guild.

Tips

  • Here is a sneaky way to make a later fight easier: in the Word Wall room, at least one of the draugr can use the Disarm shout. Lure it towards Mercer, and if it disarms him, his sword goes flying and you can grab it. He never gets it back, leaving him with only a steel dagger when you meet him again.
  • Mercer cannot be pickpocketed until after he opens the puzzle door. With the right Pickpocket perk you can then steal his enchanted Dwarven sword. The scene still plays out, with Mercer threatening Karliah with his fists and stabbing you with an invisible blade.
  • Snow Veil Sanctum cannot be entered before this quest, so there is no point in clearing it early.

Trivia

  • The skeleton in the room where you first meet Karliah is Gallus. Mercer’s own story has Karliah throwing his body down the shaft into that room, though everything else he says makes it clear who the real killer was.
  • If you lock Mercer behind the previous gate after he opens the puzzle door, the scene plays out without him in it, which is a strange sight.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Meet Mercer Frey outside Snow Veil Sanctum
Enter Snow Veil Sanctum
Find Karliah
Speak to Karliah

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Delvin Mallory is the Thieves Guild’s veteran fixer in the Ragged Flagon – master Sneak trainer, job-giver and buyer of rare stolen treasures.
Karliah is the Dunmer Nightingale framed for murder by Mercer Frey – exiled for 25 years and back for revenge in the Thieves Guild questline.
Mercer Frey is the irritable Breton Guildmaster of the Thieves Guild in Riften – and the man at the dark heart of the guild’s questline.

Creatures you will meet

Draugr are the undead Nords guarding Skyrim’s ancient tombs. Variants, shouting Deathlords, and how to survive a barrow full of them.

Locations

Snow Veil Sanctum in Skyrim: the Nordic barrow north of Windhelm for Speaking With Silence – traps, draugr, a Dragon Priest, the Disarm Word Wall and loot.
Windhelm is the ancient, snow-covered capital of Eastmarch and the Stormcloak stronghold – home of Ulfric Stormcloak’s Palace of the Kings and the Gray Quarter.
Winterhold is the ruined capital of Winterhold hold – most of it fell into the sea in the Great Collapse, leaving a handful of houses and the College of Winterhold.

Factions

The Thieves Guild hides in the Ratway beneath Riften – down on its luck, full of secrets and home to the Nightingales. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database