The Eye of Melka looks like any other bundle of bird skulls and feathers carried by the Forsworn, but it hits far harder. This unique Destruction staff copies the Fireball spell: a fiery explosion that deals 40 points of damage in a 15 foot radius, with extra damage against targets that are already burning. It is a good fit for warriors and archers who want a reliable crowd-clearing tool without investing in spells, and for mages who want a backup when their Magicka bar is empty.
Where to find it
The staff belongs to Melka, a hagraven you meet locked up in Blind Cliff Cave. Another hagraven, Petra, has taken over the place. Free Melka, kill Petra, and Melka hands you the Eye as thanks. If you would rather not do business with a hagraven, you can kill Melka instead and take it from her body. Nobody will think less of you. Probably.
Is it worth using?
Staffs draw on their own charge, not your Magicka, so the Eye works the same for a level 10 thief as for an Arch-Mage. Once the charge runs out, refill it with soul gems. Since it shares its effect with the regular Staff of Fireballs, the real reason to pick this one up is timing: you can get it fairly early, at a point where 40 points of area fire damage is a lot. Against groups of bandits or Forsworn bunched up in a cave, it is excellent. Later on you will out-damage it with your main build, but it stays a handy panic button for clustered enemies. If you play a dedicated Destruction mage, the spell version is probably what you will use day to day, and the Eye becomes a souvenir.
It also has a tiny bit of story weight. Few unique staffs come from siding with a hagraven, and choosing between Melka’s gratitude and her corpse is a nice little moral test in a game that rarely asks.
Good to know
On Xbox 360, the staff may randomly turn up on a Forsworn in the same room as Petra, so check the bodies before you decide what to do with Melka.
Stats from the Skyrim game files; locations checked against community wiki articles, written in our own words.

