A Chance Arrangement

Brynjolf’s test in Riften’s marketplace: steal Madesi’s ring and plant it on Brand-Shei.

A Chance Arrangement is your first step into the Thieves Guild. Walk through Riften and Brynjolf, a smooth-talking redhead with an eye for other people’s money, will size you up and offer you a little job. The task is a classic frame-up: steal a ring and plant it on an innocent merchant while Brynjolf keeps the crowd busy. It is a gentle introduction to sneaking and pickpocketing, and you can even back out without wrecking the questline.

How to start

Brynjolf approaches you on your first visit to Riften. He usually hangs around The Bee and Barb or the marketplace, where he runs a stall peddling his dubious Falmerblood Elixir. He opens by commenting on your coin purse, and if you dealt with the shakedown guard at the city gate he admits that man was one of his and got greedy. Ask what he has in mind and he lays out the plan.

Walkthrough

Meet Brynjolf during the day

The job only runs while the market is open, between 8 in the morning and 8 in the evening. If you agree at night, he tells you to come back then. His reason for the job: someone wants Brand-Shei taught to keep his nose out of other people’s business, and since the guild is not the Dark Brotherhood, a few days in jail will have to do.

Steal Madesi’s ring

Tell Brynjolf you are ready and he gathers the whole market round to hear about his miracle potion. Wait until everyone has stopped moving and is listening. The silver ring is in a strongbox under Madesi‘s stall, behind a locked sliding door, not in the display case on top. You can pick the lock or pickpocket the key from Madesi. Feel free to help yourself to anything else in there while you are at it.

Plant the ring on Brand-Shei

Sneak over to the crates behind Brand-Shei. He sits still watching the show, which makes him an easy target from behind the boxes. Open his pockets and place the ring in his inventory. Planting it on anyone else does not get them arrested, so make sure you pick the right Dunmer. Brynjolf wraps up his act once the deed is done.

Report back

Talk to Brynjolf to collect your pay. Soon after, a guard arrests Brand-Shei and hauls him off to Riften Jail. The next quest, Taking Care of Business, starts immediately.

Choices and consequences

You do not have to frame Brand-Shei. Skipping or failing the plant keeps him in business as a merchant with gold to trade, which is handy for low-level characters, and keeps his quest Distant Memories available. Brynjolf is disappointed, but still sees potential in you and the questline carries on as normal. You just do not get paid. Ways this can happen:

  • Getting caught stealing fails the quest.
  • Dropping the ring and telling Brynjolf you lost it fails the planting objective, but you can still finish.
  • Taking too long: the distraction eventually ends and the quest fails.
  • The law-abiding route: once the distraction starts, just walk through any door around the market. The planting fails, oddly the stealing counts as done, and you can talk to Brynjolf without committing a single crime.

Rewards

100 gold if you complete the job, plus whatever you lifted from Madesi’s strongbox.

Tips

  • You can unlock the sliding door and strongbox the night before, when far fewer people are watching.
  • Even one point in the first Pickpocket perk gives good odds of planting the ring. If you are nervous, drink a Fortify Pickpocket potion first.
  • If you are Thane of Riften, you can use the title to avoid arrest if caught, but it only works once per guard per day.

Details checked against community wiki articles and the Skyrim game files, summarised in our own words.

Objectives

Talk to Brynjolf about joining the Thieves Guild
Meet Brynjolf during daytime
Steal Madesi’s ring from his strongbox
Plant Madesi’s ring
Speak to Brynjolf

Walkthrough

Choices & consequences

Known bugs & fixes

Lore notes

Characters in this quest

Brand-Shei is the Dunmer merchant in Riften’s market – the man you frame in A Chance Arrangement, and secretly born Brandyl of House Telvanni.
Brynjolf is the smooth-talking Nord thief who recruits you into the Thieves Guild in Riften – and knows where the old Blade Esbern is hiding.
Madesi in Skyrim: a traditional Argonian jeweler in Riften’s market who gives Ringmaker and whose silver ring you lift during A Chance Arrangement.

Creatures you will meet

Locations

Riften is the canal city of the Rift – autumn forests, the Black-Briar family, the Temple of Mara and the Thieves Guild beneath its streets.
Riften Jail in Skyrim: the Rift’s prison beside Mistveil Keep – how to get past the guard, prisoners like Sibbi Black-Briar, quests and the fake escape.
The Bee and Barb in Skyrim: Riften’s inn run by Keerava and Talen-Jei – Thieves Guild start, Marcurio, Maven, unique drinks and every quest explained.

Factions

The Thieves Guild hides in the Ratway beneath Riften – down on its luck, full of secrets and home to the Nightingales. How to join, the questline and rewards.

Quest rewards

Sources checked: Fandom export (Quests), in-game
Explore the database